Home News Editorials Don’t Trade Casas or Mayer Even If It Hurts

Don’t Trade Casas or Mayer Even If It Hurts

0
11
Don't Trade Casas or Mayer Even If It Hurts
Brian Fluharty-Imagn Images

The Mead Injury Changes Everything

The Red Sox just lost their new shortstop for the season. Curtis Mead broke his wrist and will go on the injured list. He might be done for the entire year. This injury happened right after the team traded for him. The timing is terrible for a team that needed help. Bryan Joiner wrote about this on Over the Monster. He noted the team likely had more deals in mind before this crash. Now those plans are in total shambles.

The front office almost certainly wasn’t done making moves. They were looking to add more depth before the deadline. That window just slammed shut. You can’t trade a player who is already injured. The risk is too high for any other team to take. This forces the Red Sox to look inward for solutions. They have to rely on their own young talent now.

Wait, did you see the timeline on that trade? It’s a nightmare scenario. They spent the offseason building a specific infield, only to have it crumble in July. Now they’re scrambling.

Keep Casas and Mayer at All Costs

Triston Casas still has a lot to prove. Some fans might want to move him for a quick fix. That is a terrible idea right now. The team needs to see what he can do. Marcelo Mayer is another name you can’t touch. He is a top prospect who should stay in Boston. Franklin Arias might be too good to deal anyway. Joiner asked if the team believes in these players.

The answer has to be yes. Trading these guys now would send the wrong message. It shows the team doesn’t trust its own pipeline. The same doubts were once cast on Casas and Mayer. They’ve grown into key pieces of the puzzle. Moving them now would leave a huge hole in the infield. The roster is already thin after the Mead news. You don’t cut your own legs off when you’re down.

Think about the scouting reports we’ve seen on Mayer. He’s got the glove and the bat. Why would you ship him out for a guy who might be gone in October? It makes zero sense.

The Right Move Is To Wait It Out

The Red Sox must resist the urge to panic. They shouldn’t trade their top prospects for a rental. The season isn’t over yet. They can still find a path to the playoffs. The question is who stays and who goes. Joiner suggested everyone is nominally available. That is a dangerous thought for a fan.

Don’t let the front office get cute here. We’ve seen too many teams blow up their future for a short-term boost that never pans out. The playoff path is still there, just harder to navigate. They need to play the hand they have, not chase a ghost.


author avatar
Andy Mailhot